Abstract
This article explores the “Laki-laki tidak bercerita” phenomenon in Indonesia, which translates to “Men don’t share their stories.” This phrase, originating from Indonesian social media, reflects the cultural and societal pressures that often lead men to suppress their emotions and maintain a stoic facade1. The article investigates the impact of this societal expectation on Indonesian men’s mental health, including the prevalence of mental health disorders and the challenges they face in seeking help. Additionally, it examines initiatives and programs aimed at addressing this issue and promoting men’s mental well-being in Indonesia.
Introduction
The phrase “Laki-laki tidak bercerita” (“Men don’t share their stories”), which emerged from Indonesian social media, encapsulates a deeply rooted expectation in Indonesian society: men should be strong, resilient, and emotionally reserved1. This expectation can have significant implications for men’s mental health. This article aims to provide a comprehensive overview of this phenomenon, exploring its cultural and societal roots, its impact on men’s mental well-being, and the initiatives in place to address it.
Cultural and Societal Factors
Several intertwined cultural and societal factors contribute to the “Laki-laki tidak bercerita” phenomenon. Patriarchal cultural ideas, prevalent in Indonesia, promote an unequal distribution of power between genders, often leading to the suppression of women’s voices and reinforcing traditional gender roles2. Within this framework, men are often expected to be the providers and protectors, shouldering the responsibility of maintaining a strong and stoic exterior3. This can discourage men from expressing vulnerability or seeking help for emotional distress4.
From a young age, boys are often raised with the belief that emotions like sadness or fear are signs of weakness, leading them to suppress their feelings and avoid open communication about their struggles. This is further compounded by the cultural emphasis on maintaining harmony and avoiding conflict5. Openly discussing personal issues, especially those related to mental health, can be perceived as disrupting social balance or bringing shame to their families.
Impact on Men’s Mental Health
The pressure to conform to traditional masculinity norms can have detrimental effects on men’s mental health. Studies have shown a link between adherence to traditional masculinity ideologies and an increased risk of depression, anxiety, and substance abuse6. The “Laki-laki tidak bercerita” phenomenon can exacerbate these risks by preventing men from seeking help or confiding in others.
Furthermore, men in Indonesia may face unique challenges in accessing mental health services. Stigma surrounding mental illness remains prevalent, and seeking help can be perceived as a sign of weakness or failure7. This stigma, coupled with limited access to mental health resources, can create significant barriers for men seeking support.
Interestingly, research suggests that adolescent males in Indonesia have the lowest rate of visits to primary health facilities compared to other age groups4. This reluctance to seek help, even for physical health issues, underscores the deeply ingrained societal pressure on men to appear strong and self-reliant. Additionally, parenting styles can significantly influence adolescent mental health8. This highlights the need to address not only individual beliefs but also the broader family and societal contexts that shape men’s attitudes towards mental health.
Organizations Focused on Men’s Mental Health in Indonesia
Several organizations in Indonesia are dedicated to improving men’s mental health. These organizations play a crucial role in raising awareness, providing support, and advocating for better mental health services. Some notable organizations include:
- Bali Medika – Men’s Health Clinic: This LGBT-friendly clinic provides specialized services for men, including HIV prevention programs and STD testing and treatments9.
- Get Happy Indonesia: This non-profit community-based organization focuses on starting conversations and spreading knowledge about depression, mental health, and happiness. They offer educational resources and support groups to reduce stigma and promote mental well-being10.
- Indonesia Mentality Care: This community-based organization aims to increase mental health literacy in Jakarta. They bring together professionals, university students, and individuals with mental health challenges to foster understanding and support11.
- Halo Jiwa: This social enterprise provides a range of mental health services, including education, research, counseling, support groups, and mental health tests12.
- Bali Bersama Bisa: This organization offers complimentary in-person or online counseling on specific days of the week12.
These organizations, along with others, are working to create a more supportive environment for men to address their mental health needs.
Statistical Insights on Men’s Mental Health in Indonesia
While specific statistics focusing solely on men’s mental health in Indonesia are limited, available data provides valuable insights into the overall mental health landscape and the challenges faced by men.
Statistic | Male Adolescents | Female Adolescents | General Population |
|---|---|---|---|
Prevalence of psychological distress | 16.9% 13 | 30.4% 13 | Not available |
Prevalence of depression | 10.1% 13 | 14.6% 13 | 6.1% 14 |
Prevalence of emotional mental disorders | Not available | Not available | Increased from 6% in 2013 to 9.8% in 2018 14 |
Percentage of individuals with depression receiving treatment | Not available | Not available | 9% 14 |
Prevalence of mental disorders (2023) | Not available | Not available | Approximately 20% 14 |
Percentage of GDP spent on mental health disorders (2012-2030) | Not available | Not available | 21.9% 14 |
It is important to note that while male in-school adolescents reported a lower prevalence of psychological distress and depression compared to their female counterparts, there is no significant difference in the overall prevalence of mental disorders between male and female adolescents in Indonesia15. This suggests that men may be less likely to express emotional distress openly, highlighting the importance of addressing the “Laki-laki tidak bercerita” phenomenon.
Furthermore, the increase in the prevalence of emotional mental disorders in Indonesia from 6% in 2013 to 9.8% in 2018 is a concerning trend14. This underscores the need for increased awareness, prevention efforts, and improved access to mental health services.
Initiatives and Programs
Recognizing the growing concern surrounding mental health, various initiatives and programs have been implemented in Indonesia to address the “Laki-laki tidak bercerita” phenomenon and promote men’s mental well-being.
Government Initiatives:
The Indonesian government has taken steps to improve mental health services. The Healthy Indonesia Program with Family Approach includes mental health as one of its key indicators, aiming to increase access to mental health care, particularly in rural communities16. This program emphasizes home visits to eliminate barriers to accessing health services, such as travel costs and time off from work.
Technological Initiatives:
One notable technological initiative is the SATUSEHAT mobile platform, developed by the Indonesian government. This platform includes a mental health self-screening feature, allowing users to assess their mental state before seeking professional intervention17. This feature was prioritized due to rising concerns about increasing suicide rates, demonstrating a proactive approach to addressing mental health challenges.
Community-Based Initiatives:
Peer support programs have also shown promise in addressing mental health challenges among young adults in Indonesia18. These programs provide a safe and supportive space for individuals to share their experiences, connect with others, and develop coping strategies.
Organizational Efforts:
Organizations like Get Happy Indonesia and Indonesia Mentality Care are working to raise awareness about mental health issues and reduce stigma10. These organizations provide education, support groups, and resources to promote mental well-being.
These initiatives and programs demonstrate a growing commitment to addressing men’s mental health in Indonesia. By combining government efforts, technological advancements, community-based approaches, and organizational support, Indonesia can create a more comprehensive and accessible mental health system.
Conclusion
The “Laki-laki tidak bercerita” phenomenon reflects deeply ingrained cultural and societal norms in Indonesia that can have a profound impact on men’s mental health. By encouraging open communication, challenging traditional masculinity ideologies, and increasing access to mental health services, Indonesia can create a more supportive environment for men to seek help and prioritize their well-being.
Synthesis of Findings
This research has highlighted the complex interplay of cultural norms, societal expectations, and mental health in Indonesian men. The “Laki-laki tidak bercerita” phenomenon, rooted in traditional masculinity and societal pressures, presents a significant challenge to men’s mental well-being. This expectation for men to remain stoic and emotionally reserved can contribute to increased risks of mental health disorders, such as depression and anxiety, and hinder help-seeking behavior6. The reluctance of men to visit primary health facilities further underscores the deeply ingrained pressure to appear strong and self-reliant4.
While statistical data specifically focusing on men’s mental health in Indonesia is limited, available research suggests a concerning prevalence of mental health issues among men14. The increase in the prevalence of emotional mental disorders in recent years emphasizes the urgency of addressing this issue14.
However, there is growing awareness and action to address the “Laki-laki tidak bercerita” phenomenon. Organizations like Get Happy Indonesia and Indonesia Mentality Care are actively working to raise awareness, reduce stigma, and provide support for men’s mental health10. They offer educational resources, support groups, and platforms for open communication, challenging the traditional norms that discourage men from seeking help.
The Indonesian government is also taking significant steps to improve mental health services. The Healthy Indonesia Program with Family Approach, with its focus on mental health and home visits, aims to increase access to care, particularly in rural communities16. Furthermore, the SATUSEHAT mobile platform, with its mental health self-screening feature, provides a readily accessible tool for individuals to assess their mental well-being17.
Challenging traditional masculinity is crucial to creating a more supportive environment for men’s mental health. By redefining masculinity to include vulnerability and emotional expression, society can encourage men to seek help without fear of judgment. Initiatives like peer support programs, which provide safe spaces for sharing experiences and developing coping strategies, can be particularly effective in fostering open communication and challenging traditional norms18.
Addressing the “Laki-laki tidak bercerita” phenomenon requires a continued commitment to raising awareness, reducing stigma, and improving access to mental health services. By promoting open communication, challenging traditional masculinity, and providing comprehensive support, Indonesia can empower men to prioritize their mental health and well-being.
Works cited
1. Fenomena Bahasa “Laki-Laki Tidak Bercerita” di Media Sosial – Scientia Indonesia, accessed December 25, 2024, https://scientia.id/2024/12/22/fenomena-bahasa-laki-laki-tidak-bercerita-di-media-sosial/
2. Challenging the patriarchal culture; Feminist critical discourse analysis of the Indonesian environmental heroines – UI Scholars Hub, accessed December 25, 2024, https://scholarhub.ui.ac.id/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1173&context=wacana
3. STATE OF THE WORLD’S FATHER | 1 – Equimundo, accessed December 25, 2024, https://www.equimundo.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/SOWF-Country-Report-Indonesia-2015.pdf
4. Comparing Indonesian men’s health-seeking behavior and likelihood to suffer from illness across sociodemographic factors, accessed December 25, 2024, https://www.jomh.org/articles/10.31083/jomh.2021.078
5. PERBEDAAN GAYA BAHASA LAKI-LAKI DAN PEREMPUAN PADA PENUTUR BAHASA INDONESIA DAN ACEH Said Iskandar Zulkarnain & Naria Fitri, accessed December 25, 2024, https://jurnal.ar-raniry.ac.id/index.php/equality/article/download/4486/2948
6. Kenali Toxic Masculinity, Konsep Laki-Laki Tidak Boleh Sedih dan Menangis – KlikDokter, accessed December 25, 2024, https://www.klikdokter.com/psikologi/kesehatan-mental/apa-itu-toxic-masculinity
7. Analisis kesehatan mental di masyarakat – Jurnal Arka Institute, accessed December 25, 2024, https://jurnal.arkainstitute.co.id/index.php/nautical/article/download/1051/799/3523
8. FAKTOR-FAKTOR YANG MEMPENGARUHI KESEHATAN MENTAL PADA REMAJA Factors Affecting Mental Health In Adolesents, accessed December 25, 2024, https://journal.umpr.ac.id/index.php/jsm/article/download/4522/2935/17301
9. Free Telephone Counseling Hotlines in Indonesia – OpenCounseling, accessed December 25, 2024, https://blog.opencounseling.com/hotlines-id/
10. Get Happy Indonesia | MHIN – Mental Health Innovation Network, accessed December 25, 2024, https://www.mhinnovation.net/organisations/get-happy-indonesia
11. Indonesia Mentality Care | MHIN, accessed December 25, 2024, https://www.mhinnovation.net/organisations/indonesia-mentality-care
12. Finding Mental Health Care in South Asia and Southeast Asia – HeadsUpGuys, accessed December 25, 2024, https://headsupguys.org/how-to-find-mental-health-care-in-south-asia-and-southeast-asia/
13. Exploring Mental Health Issues and Priorities in Indonesia Through Qualitative Expert Consensus, accessed December 25, 2024, https://clinical-practice-and-epidemiology-in-mental-health.com/VOLUME/20/ELOCATOR/e17450179331951/FULLTEXT/
14. Exploring Mental Health Issues and Priorities in Indonesia Through Qualitative Expert Consensus, accessed December 25, 2024, https://clinical-practice-and-epidemiology-in-mental-health.com/VOLUME/20/ELOCATOR/e17450179331951/PDF/
15. Gender Differences in Depression in the General Population of Indonesia: Confounding Effects – PMC, accessed December 25, 2024, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8253638/
16. Indonesia: Shackling Reduced, But Persists | Human Rights Watch, accessed December 25, 2024, https://www.hrw.org/news/2018/10/02/indonesia-shackling-reduced-persists
17. Reflecting Mental Health Situation in Indonesia with SATUSEHAT | by DTO Kemenkes RI, accessed December 25, 2024, https://medium.com/@dtokemkes/reflecting-mental-health-situation-in-indonesia-with-satusehat-e76bd1e0c8ce
18. INSAN Jurnal Psikologi dan Kesehatan Mental – e-Journal UNAIR, accessed December 25, 2024, https://e-journal.unair.ac.id/JPKM/article/download/31110/pdf/126102